If your favorite team had to choose between these 2 players....

Question

who would you rather have them pick?

Andruw Jones or Barry Zito?

Answer 1

I would have to take Zito and put him in the bullpen as a left-handed specialist because his overall stats are terrible but has a decent 1.36 WHIP v. lefties.

IF I HAD TO CHOOSE is the key though.

Answer 2

Zito

Answer 3

Alas, I would pick Barry Zito.  He has shown signs of life every now and again this season.  Plus, he only pitches every 5th day.

Answer 4

Jones cause zito's contract is alot bigger

Answer 5

I take Jones because pitchers affect the game more

Answer 6

Zito. He's only going to hurt you every 4th day. Jones'll kill you night after night.

I've been watching him go 0 for 3 ALL YEAR LONG!! He did it again tonight...

edit - make that 0 for 4, flew out to end the game with a runner on. Dodgers lose 2-1. Now down 2 games in the NL West. The Manny era begins tomorrow, WHO DO WE SIT?

Answer 7

Barry Zito.

Andruw Jones just sucks too much.

Answer 8

mmm oooshh hard one

Zito,  the offense would give extra support every time he pitched XD plus he can sing/play guitar that's somethin

Answer 9

I would rather eat nails sorry!

Answer 10

Zito. He has actually kept the Giants in the game the last few outings.  

Answer 11

As a Red Sox fan, I'd take both of them. Then I'd set up some sort of sting operation to get compromising photos of Yankees GM Ken Cashman.  After I did that, I'd make him take both Jones and Zito in a trade and sign them to long term contracts.

Answer 12

Zito. He can wake up one day and remember how to pitch. Andrew Jones just doesnt have a quick enough bat anymore

Answer 13

Zito. 5 wins is better than batting a light .170 average. Also Zito only comes once every 5 games so its not that bad.

Answer 14

Andruw jones

Answer 15

Ewck. I'd rather have Manny back. And HE was BAD!