Im in a keeper league for fantasy football. Who should I keep out of these 2 guys?

Question

We have to give up a draft pick 2 rds ahead of where we got the guy last yr, so say I got someone in rd 8 of last yrs draft, this yr I wouldnt get a 6th rder this yr. I got Adrian Peterson in the 7th rd so Im giving up a 5th to keep him obviously. But I got Lynch in the 6th rd and would give up a 4th. My other option is I got Michael Turner in the 12th and would give up a 10th, should I keep Lynch or Turner??

Answer 1

I would say Turner cause Matt Ryan will probably not do so good having to start your rookie year can be tough that means Turner will get the ball 85% of the time

Answer 2

Lynch he is younger and he is the bread and butter to the bills offense the Falcons are just horrible at least the bills are just below average

Answer 3

You should get Turner but not because he will neccesarily have a better year. I think Atlanta will struggle. But you dont want to draft 1-2-3-6-7-8..... Losing 2 rounds is very crucial this early. Losing a 10th rdr splits it up and at the very most Lynch will average 3-5 pts a game more that Turner. Turner could also out average Lynch. But the chances of your 4th rdr scoring 3-5 pts per game more than your 10th rounder are almost a gaurantee.

Go Turner, and congrats on holding onto him all last season, this is the year it finnaly pays off!!!!

Answer 4

Let Lynch go, he's on the decline in his career, and won't have as many int, or tackles as past years.  Michael Turner is moving into a starting role and gurantees good fantasy points.  The only threat is him wearing down, or breaking down in that role over an entire season.

Answer 5

That's a tough one.  Hopefully you've got some time to consider?  See how pre-season goes and see in Lynch gets in any more trouble.  Lynch is the better back and on a better team but not by a lot.  Right now I would keep Lynch (younger too).

Answer 6

get rid of lynch....He will not do that great because he is not the star runningback. A 4th round pick is a good starting QB or a WR why pass on Lynch. You might still be able to get Turner with that. (I dont know how the Keeper leagues work sorry)  but drop lynch get 4th round draft pick

Answer 7

Keep Turner. Hes much more valuble a a 10th round pick then lynch at a 4th!