In "Gone Baby Gone," do you think the little girl should have remained with Morgan Freeman's character?

Question

I have to confess, I would have left the little girl with Morgan Freeman's character instead of returning her to her mother. She would have had a true shot at a good future instead of growing up amidst druggie trash.

What do you think?

Answer 1

I think he made the right decision, but the right decision is not always the best one.  If I was in his shoes I would not have put my marriage at risk for ANYTHING.  He should have carried on with his life knowing that the little girl was alive and well cared for.

Answer 2

I WOULD HAVE LEFT HER WITH MORGAN FREEMAN