In rugby union would you prefer your out-half to be a) A good kicker b) A good runner?

Question

basically whats more important kicking or running

Answer 1

They need a balance of good running, kicking and distribution skills. Rugby has so many variables that your fly half needs to be able to adjust to these e.g. A blustery day needs a good runner and passer heading into the wind, and a good tactical kicker with the wind at their backs. They also need to adjust to differing defensive tactics; rush defense may require a a cheeky chip in behind or a wide pass into space, or sliding defensive may require him to run a bit more, asking questions of the defense, with runners supporting on multiple angles. Just look at the world class fly halves, this is what they are all capable of

Answer 2

Definatly a better runner

Answer 3

b.

Answer 4

Running. A more important skill, however, is passing.

Answer 5

the out-half has to be a good kicker. Because of where he is in relation to the scrum, he is the one that has to take the long kicks upfield. If he isn't a good runner, then you wont have as many attacking options but if he can't releave the pressure with a defensive kick, then you will be up against it all game.