In spite of the Giant's record, would you consider Tim Lincecum as a Cy Young candidate?

Question

In spite of the Giant's record, would you consider Tim Lincecum as a Cy Young candidate?

Answer 1

yes, definitely.

He should win it. he has so much talent.

Answer 2

I would! Though other's wouldn't because he is on a losing team!

Answer 3

Yes.Look at history.You dont have to be on a contender to win the Cy Young.J.R.Richards(astros).Clemens when he was on the jays.Schilling when he was on the Phillies.

Answer 4

YES YES YES!! He's young and yes talented! Although I like the Giants a lot, I think they're lowering his record a bit...

Answer 5

yes he has alot of tallent and his record stands for its self but his team sucks  

Answer 6

I would, but he'll never get it, because he's on a loing team.

Answer 7

I would definitely consider him as a Cy Young candidate people really underestimate him.

Answer 8

yes definitely!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

u dont know how much i love the giants and tim lincecum!!!!!

but guess what.. the giants 'pen just blew the win for lincecum again...wow.

but i definetly think hes better than any  other starter in the n.l.

Answer 9

absolutely a cy young candidate, he should be in the top three

Answer 10

Yes. He should win it because of how he dominated the whole league. I wish the A's had Timmy.  

Answer 11

i really think tim lincecum is going to win the Cy young this year because the kid has so much talent with averaging 10 or more strikeouts per game this guy is on fire.  

Answer 12

yeah he will be the cy young if he keeps this up he is doing amazing this year. wonder if he got more run support  

Answer 13

He could be in short list of potential candidates/winners. However he will need some additional wins, and with their offense, or lack of, wont come easy.

Answer 14

Yes. Tim Lincecum is going to be one of the great ones.

Answer 15

he will definitly finish in the top 5 but he wont win it. Probably Brandon Webb will win it or Edison Volquez.

Answer 16

Yea he should get more consideration because of that. He has 11 wins with a team that doesn't score a lot of runs.  If he played on a eam that gave him a little bit more run support he would have at least two more wins.