In this dialogue, do you agree with the philosopher or the tree?

Question

This is a dialogue between a tree and a man and some other animals on the nature of "who we are?"

It's philosophical in nature - but it's a good, fun read - and figurative too.

Please give me your opinions on the philosophical piece. Does it show well the arguments of materialism against non-materialism? Was the dialogue thought-provoking? What did you think of the style?

link: http://mlogy.blogspot.com/2008/09/cameo-tree-and-its-shadow.html

Many Thanks

Answer 1

I will agree with the philosopher. The tree's knowledge is limited by the fact that he is a tree and so cannot see beyond it.