Question:

Instant replay starts Thursday in Baseball, Good for the game or Bad?

by Guest55636  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

Instant replay starts Thursday in Baseball, Good for the game or Bad?

 Tags:

   Report
Answer The Question I've Same Question Too

10 ANSWERS

Sort By: Date  |  Rating

  1. Why slow down the game any more. The game has survived just fine for close to 150 years. Human error is a part of life. It is the best game going, if it's not broke don't fix it.

    But then the AL thinks the DH is an improvement, so go ahead and let the AL play with it.


  2. If done the right way it can be a good thing.

  3. People are not understand that replay is very limited resoruce.

    its only going ot be use for HOMERUNS fair/foul or orver the wall

  4. I don't like it at all baseball needs to change many things, replay isn't one of them. Start with a salary cap, and weekly roid testing.

    -YANKEE FAN SINCE BIRTH.

  5. are you sure it starts thursday?! wow

    i have to say i would prefer it not at all.. so "Bad."

    umpires' contraversial calls are a part of the game.

    and i could go on and on, but ill stop right there =]

  6. Mixed feelings about this.  If my team hits a homer and it's called foul, I wish the play could be reviewed.  On the other hand, If my team hits a foul and the ump calls it fair and a HR, that's OK too.

    See, it can go either way.  

    Probably more good than bad tho.

  7. I think it might be bad. Baseball is refereed by umpires who go to school a long time for this stuff. Their good at their job and they do make their calls most of the time right. I think replay may only help a couple calls but not many. It may be just a waste of time. And when you think of it. What if the ball is a close foul ball but clearly foul. They pull out the replay and the pitcher loses his rythm having to wait then end up doing bad.

  8. Should have had it last year, barrett dropped the ball but holliday didnt tag the bag.

  9. Good, nothing sucks more than a ump for doesn't know what the h**l he's doing. & this way everything's fair : ]

  10. i think its bad cuz it changes alot about baseball

    it never had replay and i dont think it ever should (maybe only for home runs) other than that its bad
You're reading: Instant replay starts Thursday in Baseball, Good for the game or Bad?

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 10 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.
Register Now