Is 3 weeks for Josh Carr too harsh?

Question

Kerr will get 3 weeks for headbutting, and Carrs wasnt as bad as that, just seems unjust for something so small, i know he has a bad record but geez. Barry got seven for a king hit, making 3 seem like so much more.

Answer 1

I'd say he got 1 week for the offence and 2 weeks for being Josh Carr, considering how having 19 men on the field isn't cheating if the one who came on doesn't touch the ball (now that's a nice link, oh yeah).

Answer 2

Compared to what Hall got it was harsh, and considering the Swans cheated at the end of their match with 19 men on the ground and dont get any penalty, i agree it is harsh.

Answer 3

If he was Lloyd, Judd or someone like that he would have got less or even got off. Thats the AFL for you.