Is American Idol "jumping the shark" by adding another judge?

Question

Is American Idol "jumping the shark" by adding another judge?

Answer 1

Maybe

Or Paula got to strange

To balance Paula Off

Answer 2

It will show how stupid Paula really is......

Answer 3

A little, it depends on the chemistry. They used to have guests celebrity judges that seemed okay, but they only had nice things to say.

Answer 4

I think they're just trying to boost ratings.  I'll give it a chance before I complain.  I watch mostly because of Ryan.  I love him.

Answer 5

I think it's a way to push Paula out.

Answer 6

Yes they are.  Leave well enough alone...or, If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

Answer 7

i think so. it's just not natural to add another judge

Answer 8

they just want more ratings.

it's a stupid idea.

Answer 9

its silly i really dont see the point it would be ready to get rid of paula's drunk a**

Answer 10

I think they want to try something different.  And this is one way.  As long as they don't mess with Ryan Seacrest, I don't care what they do.  4 judges might cause more bickering.  lol  two against two!