Is Carlos Quentin a good keeper for my fantasy league? Or is this a fluke year?

Question

I have to decide between Quentin and Carl Crawford. I already have speed on my team so I don't need Crawford for that. Do you think Quentins bat will remain this hot into next year?

Answer 1

I would keep Crawford for sure.

Answer 2

quentin is a legitimate talent. he was a top prospect on arizona before being shipped to chitown. however, crawford is a great player too. i think you probably should keep crawford from a value standpoint unless your league favors power hitters (walks, obp, ops...). if you have too much speed maybe you can keep quentin instead of a different player, or try to deal speed.