Is Nathan Buckley a superstar of AFL??

Question

In comparison to all players in the history of the game..

Answer 1

He sure is he has won every acalade in football there is to win except a grand final and that is a team effort to achieve that.  He can kick mark  tackle and reads the play very well and is a good leader.  Maybe I am a little biased, I do barrack for Collingwood

Answer 2

No, superstar status are reserved for the likes of Carey, Ablett , Hird etc

A champion of the game yes, but not a superstar...

Answer 3

Yes

I would put him in the top 100.

He is finished now though.

Answer 4

One word, Premierships

Answer 5

yes, he will always be................

Answer 6

I'd have him at the cut-off point, probably leaning towards no.  Superstars inevitably lead teams to premierships, and while he came close in 2002, he's never done that.  But certainly the individual accolades are there to back up the claim.

Answer 7

Yes he is

Answer 8

I certainly regard Bux as a superstar ,he is captain of Collingwood ,he inspires others actions by his consistency and ball gathering abilities ,strength ,pace and overall determination .He has played in numerous finals ,also an all Australian player .He also recieved a Brownlow medal .Not many players have those accolades .

Answer 9

in comparison to all the AFL players in history id say no. hes been around awhile but hes not the best.

Answer 10

Was, isn't anymore.

Answer 11

Yes. But he's one of many superstars.

Answer 12

Yes. He has won a Brownlow Medal, a Norm Smith Medal and a  host of Copeland Trophies (Collingwood Best and Fairest). That is evidence enough that he is one of the all time greats. Shame he moved from Brisbane where he could've won some premierships.

Answer 13

No way, he is a good player but that's all he has ever been, not really a consistent game breaker and what a whinger, cries to the umpires all the time.  Past his used by date 5 years ago.  He is slow and breaks down all the time.

Answer 14

he is a huge superstar

Answer 15

No Way