Is Tom Brady the best ever?

Question

Is Tom Brady the best ever?

Answer 1

He's good, but the best ever I personally don't think so.  I would put him in the top 10 QB's of all time, but to say he's the best is debatable.

Answer 2

no no no

Answer 3

No, John Elway is.

Answer 4

.....no.....

Answer 5

Define best.  Dan Marino was an amazing passer but never won a Super Bowl.  John Elway was THE guy you'd want to lead your team back in the 4th quarter for years but he wasn't considered a great QB by many until we won a Super Bowl, then another.  Joe Montana had far from a rocket arm, and always had an amazing team around him.  He just won Super Bowls.  The best ever....?  Not yet.  His Super Bowl resume says yes, but keep putting up numbers for another 5 years and I might be ready to say yes.

Answer 6

Nope  

Answer 7

Nope.  The Top 3 QB's, (1 as best) are:

1.  Brett Favre

2.  Dan Marino

3.  John Elway

Answer 8

No...Joe Montana is...but Tom Brady is the best QB in the NFL today, and probably #3 all-time behind Joe Montana and Terry Bradshaw...Peyton lovers, get your head out his a s s...*LOL*...Super Bowls-Brady 3, Peyton 1

Answer 9

I have to give kudos where kudos are deserved... Yes, he is a fabulous QB..however...I have to admit, even though I'm a Cowboys fan, that I LOVED the fact that the Giants spanked his pretty a$$!!!!

Answer 10

No, what would qualify him as best ever?  Is he even close to approaching any significant records?  Brady is good and will likely be a hall of famer, but people only started even mentioning him as a "great" this past season.  That can almost directly be attributed to the acquisition of Randy Moss and Wes Welker.  Before they were on the team, he never threw for more than 28 TD's in a season. 28 is pretty d**n good, but it's not something you start mentioning in the same breath as Marino, Montana or Favre.  Especially since he only did it once before this last year.

Answer 11

no he isnt...joe montana is. tom brady isnt flawless in the superbowl   (3-1) but montana is (4-0)....i think that is all the arguement that is needed.....

Answer 12

no my opinion, Dan the man is the best but thats my opinion

even Favre said that Marino was the best to play the game, dont believe me? watch the ESPYs he said it on stage you dumbasses

Answer 13

maybe the gayest ever

Answer 14

Uh yeah that would be a GIANT NO!!!!!!!!!! Try comparing him with Joe Montana, Steve Young, Terry Bradshaw, Dan Marino, Peyton Manning, John Elway, even Farve there is no comparison. Oh yeah and I don't know if any of those guys were on teams that cheated. Wait let me check - No they weren't.

Answer 15

best ever what. there are tons of QB's that are better than Brady

Answer 16

h**l Yea, adn I am not even a fan of the patriots or anything. His work ethic makes him the greatest ever.  

Answer 17

I do believe that no question when Tom Brady's career is over he will be the greatest quarterback ever. Many people think the same about Peyton Manning, but the way I see it, Peyton Manning and two pro bowl wide receivers, a pro bowl tight end, and a few pro bowl lineman, for his whole career. Until the 2007 season, Tom Brady didn't have any of those. He may have a had a pro bowl lineman, im not sure. None the less, three superbowls speaks for itself.

Answer 18

Hold your horses buckaroo. Tom Brady has a long way to go to be called the best ever.

Answer 19

no troy smith is better than tom brady

Answer 20

Nope, he's solid but Peyton is better and its too premature to say he's the best

Answer 21

Right now, yes he is.

All time Terry Bradshaw  

Answer 22

in a word, NO!!! and he is not on his way to be the best ever either, is he a good QB? yeah sure, too bad He's as arrogant as they come and unaware of the fact that he is only PART of the team.