Is derek anderson and torry holt for matt shaub aaron rodgers welker and edge fair for both sides??

Question

i am doing the trade with my best friend who doesn't know much about football and i'd feel bad if i take advantage of him so is the trade fair he gets the 4 people i get the 2. his backup is campbell who is shaky and he has coles and bolden at other 2 wr. please tell me if i am ripping him of or if it is fair

Answer 1

That's really nice of you, but you're way overcompensating for what you're getting in return. Holt is terrific, and Anderson I love, but he still hasn't proved he can produce consistently and many are still waiting to see if last year was a one-hit wonder. Welker is an excellent wideout, Rodgers could do well considering he has two great wideouts (Jennings & Driver) and a good TE (Donald Lee), Schaub has incredible chemistry throwing the ball to one of the top 3 WR in the game (Andre Johnson) and will be throwing all day as the Texans have no rushing attack, and while Edge should be due for a down year he's still a starter, I think that is much too much to trade, you're being unfair for yourself in this 4 for 2.

If you really want to make the trade however I think Anderson and Holt for Welker, Edge, and one of those QBs, either Rodgers or Schaub, but not both, is more than equitable

Answer 2

Well, you are giving up 4 players for 2 so you are trying to make it fair.  If Shaub stays healthy he could put up big numbers and holt should be big since Bruce is no longer there.  I can't really say if it is fair or not because the season is too early but for now, it wouldn't hurt to give it a shot.