Is it Favre or Vick?

Question

Who do you think is making a bigger mess? When Vick killed dogs or while Favre is trying to quit, stay, or be traded?

Answer 1

equal.

Answer 2

It's not really fair to compare the two.  I guess I would say Vick was involved in a bigger mess because he got into a bunch of trouble with the law and he pretty much threw away his career and his future.  I think Favre couldn't take that he wasn't ever going to play football again and he put a lot of pressure on the Greenbay Packers and Aaron Rodgers just because he wanted to play.  Both situations are ridiculous, but Favre was involved in the lesser mess because he wasn't involved with any illegal activity.

Answer 3

I understand what you mean you are not saying who committed the worse crime but as far as Media coverage. I would have to say Brett this man was covered 24/7 on every channel reg shows were canceled so they could rehashed the same thing over and over and on here it ruled the boards and still has not stopped here nor TV. And this has been going on for I believe a month. And as it was said last night it has only started. For one to assume you don't know that the killing of dogs is worse is really a low blow..

Answer 4

The guy who commited a crime idiot.

Answer 5

Are you serious? Can you use the bathroom by yourself, or do you need help?

Answer 6

Let's think about it. Favre is playing this year. Vick is not. Do I have to continue and discuss the difference between being a convicted felon and just being a jerk, or will that suffice?

Answer 7

Vick aint do **** wrong. Those were his dogs so he can do what he want. People go around ******* animals but thats okay...just dont beat them huh?... Thats B.S.

If Favre wants to come back cant nobody gone say no. Watch the jets be raw as h**l dis yeat

Answer 8

vick by far where is favre still in the nfl and where is vick in jail yea this is a dumb question

Answer 9

well farve is now back in the nfl, and lets look where vick is. i think that says who made bigger mistake

Answer 10

Vick but it isn't really comparable.

Answer 11

Favre is a spoiled pro athlete who is 38, acting 14. Vick is in jail for committing crimes against helpless animals. I'd go with Vick for the biggest stooge.

Answer 12

I can't compare the two situations.  Brett is just being a whiny spoiled brat but he wasn't involved in an illegal activity & the abuse of innocent dogs.  

Answer 13

they both suck

Answer 14

That isn't even a comparison, Vick is a sick b*****d who should never play another game of football again.

Brett is a highly respected man by Packer fans everywhere, the respect he earned that should play football for as long as he feels his body will carry on.

Answer 15

Vick, because Favre didn't break the law.  Vick killed dogs, and got put in jail.  Favre is just making a big deal about retirement.  Although it is annoying, it's not as wrong as what Vick did.

Answer 16

Stupid queston!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  You can't compare the killing of many innocent animals to a player retiring and unretiring again.  ONCE AGAIN.... THIS IS A STUPID QUESTION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Answer 17

still vick, hands down. favre was just confused about whether or not he wanted to keep playing. vick did something illegal that turned not only the football fans across the world on him, but also people who don't even care about football and are just animal lovers