Is it true that CHINA harvests organs from it's many prisoners executed?

Question

I just watched Nat. Geographic and it said that CHINA executes at least 10,000 prisoners every year. That the Chinese culture/beliefs is against donating so China has hardly any donated organs by it's citizenry. Ambulances standing by when executing these people to TAKE their organs!!

True or no?Doesn't this make for a huge conflict in the interest of humanity to imprison, then slavework, then pilfer the corpses?

Your thoughts?

Answer 1

It was officially true until it hit western media and then the gov't made it officially untrue.

Personally I think if a man murders a family, he is not paying his debt to society by tax payers paying for him to live for the next 40 years.  I think the prisoner owes it to donate organs, it's the only thing he is capable of doing to help society.  That and making license plates.

Ask yourself if it's better to let a little girl die because you wouldn't want to violite the rights of an already dead prisoner or not.

EDIT: Are you or are you not currently wearing your tinfoil hat? Best put it on before China takes over from the liberal American media currently censoring your brainwaves.

Answer 2

The part about the executions is not compltely true. Until this year the US executed more people than any other in the world. This year due to a 6 month moratorium on executions while the supreme court reviewed whether or not it was cruel and unusual China exceeded the US. We will beat them next year by far.

I am not proud of it simply because so many( about 10%) are innocent. I am just basing that on a study of cases where DNA evidence was available in Illinois, and the people were executed prior to the availability  of DNA testing.

I do not know about the organ donation, but I would be suspicious if you found that at the same source.

Answer 3

False.

Don't use your imagination to make decision.

Learn more about China,and coem to China by yourself.You'll find it's much different from your imagination.

http://www.aboutcn.info

Answer 4

what can you say? china is the country with the most number of slavery and tortured by the their own race. but when you were in china, chinese will deny it. of course because the government limit them. they even dont have any english channel (cctv 9- still have a chinese limits) or any programs in television that can burst out the governments wrong-doing. so chinese are like living in a box, that they're not aware of the bad things that happening within their ground.

Answer 5

It is true that China executes more prisoners then any other country in the world. It is also likely that they do remove the organs of their prisoners once they are dead. I would not doubt such a thing from a nation that kills their baby girls in order to control the population.

Answer 6

I have a friend who is a liver transplant doctor, he is having a really hard time right now, trying to decide what to do about the immoral practices that are going on, he really wants to be out of the transplant sector of medicine

Answer 7

true, but onyl to a certain extent. china has been the target of much false criticism. it's really up to you if you want to believe it, but seriously speaking, out of all the alleged cases, only about 10% are proven to be true.



in china, many people slink to underhand means just to discredit a particular person. it is not surprising that all these are acutally attempts of people to discredit others.

please do more research though, before generalising.

Answer 8

ABOUT:It was officially true until it hit western media and then the gov't made it officially untrue.

Personally I think if a man murders a family, he is not paying his debt to society by tax payers paying for him to live for the next 40 years. I think the prisoner owes it to donate organs, it's the only thing he is capable of doing to help society. That and making license plates.

Ask yourself if it's better to let a little girl die because you wouldn't want to violite the rights of an already dead prisoner or not.

I like this idea.

Answer 9

I think dis is a true thing .. We must all stop dis violent act ..

Answer 10

Its not as true as some might make it out to be, the western country twisted many things and stretched the truth. People writing on this page probably have NEVER been to China and they are talking all this c**p after seeing how bad their own country is,and how its going way in to the dumps.The people they execute are only people on death row, or people that are terrorists, mass murders, or done something horribly bad to the extent.

  Well, THIS IS MY OWN OPINION:  Back in the days in England don't people chop off their hands when saying a bad word against the royals, or get their head chopped off if they steal chickens. Oh and china is soooo" horrible"!!! I think that they should do that, there is nothing wrong with executing people thats been doing the absolutely worse thing possible, and getting their corpses for medical reasons and if it could save somebody's life. If I was ever ruling some perfect world

( which I highly doubt, because I will be h**l to deal with), I would do the same thing, and I would be cutting off the balls of every d**n rapist, along with the heads of every other murders. I don't see anything wrong with this!!! s***w ALL THAT OPPOSE!!!!!

Answer 11

You do know that in July 1st 2006 the China government banned the practise of selling organs and rewrote the donor transplantation laws.

I can't denial that there maybe some illegal organ selling by corrupted officials, but then again it is illegal.

Much of the data in that link and the you tude link is a good couple of years before this July 1st 2006 deadline.

Do you have any figures that are up to date?

Edit: Thanks for the link you do know that

a) The date you quoted changes with that is todays date.

     Its now quoted 1 August.

b) The references  that are around the bottom of the page  

     are either before 1 July 2006 or around that date.

c) The latest reference dated Jul 08 2008 uses data from

    1999-2005 again before the 1 July 2006, the rest is on

     hearsay and is not backed up by fact.

d) The death sentence rules have been rewritten over the last

     2 years and now a person can only be killed if allowed

     by Chinese highest court and not by the local courts

e) Some animal rights groups and supporters openly support

     that dead prisoners organs should be used for transplants

     rather than use these animal growth tissues for humans.

If they are illegally doing stuff, I would like something to be done based on hard facts and not hearsay.

Answer 12

I'm really, really happy that I do not live in China!

Answer 13

YES!  Their prisons are like people farms, they keep their blood-type records, chk their organs, kidneys, heart, liver & eyes to see if they're healthy for harvesting.  When you go to a Chinese transplant site it's like a menu at a restaurant!  Pick your organ and they'll check out/whack one of the caged animals, tailor-made just for you!

SICK INHUMANE MONSTERS!

I just saw on World News that the athletes from other countries will not train there until just before the Olympic meet will they go there because their pollution in so thick you cannot see! I wish ppl would Boycott the Chinese Olympics.

Why do we continue to import from there?  Saving money is one thing, but at what cost overall??  We should be much more self-sustained and isolationist, it would probably help our economy to do so.

Make them stop these violations to humanity & our environment!

Answer 14

Yes, it is true! The donor organs are usually from s*x criminals. s*x criminals have extremely healthy internal organs since they are always excited. This excitement is caused by the internal organs' secretion glands ability to produce liquids at a superhuman rate.

So the execution of s*x criminals in China is justifiable and for a good cause. These people cannot be rehabilitated and their healthy organs save lives.

The USA allows s*x criminals to be released into society for good behavior in prison. These s*x criminals re-enter society and continue to destroy more lives and create fear in society.

So who is the real monster here:  America's Criminal Law or China's pragmatism?

Great research Asker! God bless you and the USA

Answer 15

Yes, it's true but I can assured you that the Government will deny it.  Btw, there are also some heartless people who killed innocent people for their organs to sell on the black market too.  Organs harvesting is big money in China.