Is it true that asking Hon'ble speaker Mr.Somnath to resign means Hon'ble President of India too to resign?

Question

Because Left Parties supported President during Presidential Elections ?

Answer 1

Mr.Somnath Chatterjee has all along been a

CPI-M member.The President has been a die hard Congresswoman for most of her life.So,

the question of her resignation doesn't arise.

Even in the case of the Speaker,the CPI-M is

virtually asking him to resign only to muster the extra vote against the government,although outwardly the party fools the public by stating

that the decision to resign is Mr.Chatterjee's.

This is called double-speak.But then politics and chicanery go hand in hand.Today's friend is

tomorrow's enemy and day-after-tomorrow's

friend again.

Answer 2

Mr. Somnath Chatterji should have declared his independence the day he was elected speaker.

He does not have to resign, his friends want him to, but it is upto him.

Similarly the President once elected is for the term of office, It is not up to anyone to recall.

You can not recall your MP once elected even if majority of his constituent hate him.

You can not even fire a chaprasi on whims.

Answer 3

No. I wonder your political ignorance !

Answer 4

no your presumption is not correct and is absolutely childish.

Answer 5

I feel in a way, Yes.

Well u can't really ask the speaker to vote for or against a particular party, as he/she once elected becomes unbiased to the house. He only votes in case its a tie, at that time though he might go with the thoughts of his party or decide to go against them and sacrifice his post as the speaker and a supporter of that party who's member he was previously.

Its seriously a big dilemma for the speaker if he's asked to vote..when he definitely shouldn't b asked at the 1st place.

Answer 6

No its not like that.

pkn