Is josh hamilton and ian kinsler for elsbary bj upton and ryan ludwik fair?

Question

i get the 1st 2 rangers i need runs desparately and can afford to give up ludwik but need upton's speed only source of steals

Answer 1

I think you'd be coming out on top.

Hamilton and Kinsler are on fire with no signs of letting up, and Kinsler has stolen 17 bases already.

Good luck.

Answer 2

Go for it. I've got Josh Hamilton on my team, and he will surely carry me to a title (or close to one), and I picked him up off of FA at the beginning of the year! Losing ellsbury means losing steals, but im not quite sold on ludwick, which on the other hand i am very sold on Hamilton. He will be close to winning the triple crown this year, and especially if this is a keeper league, i'd do it, cuz Hamilton will likely be a productive, no, a superstar outfielder for years to come. you can find speed on fa, but dont pass up this rbi and avg monger. and kinsler's not half-bad either ;)

Answer 3

Kinsler & hamilton are both playing insane right now... maybe trade soriano?

Answer 4

it's fair i think. kinsler and hamilton are on fire right now. ludwick is also good but if you have good OF, then you can make this trade. upton strikes out way too much.

Answer 5

do it