Is planet x a brown dwarf or a red giant? i hear both but i cant decide!?

Question

brown dwarf or red giant?

Answer 1

pile of c**p

Answer 2

The simple answer is that Planet X is a figment of the imagination of 2012 hoaxers. Neither red giants nor brown dwarves are planets. A red giant is a star and a brown dwarf is an object intermediate between a star and a giant planet. This lack of understanding should tell you something about the intelligence of the people who make these claims.

Answer 3

We have to ask ourselves... does it really matter what it is? Well, it can't be a red giant because that's a type of star, and a star isn't a planet... but if we are going to follow the logic set by the 2012ers what the heck?

I thought it was just some normal planet, but then another user pointed out that it was supposed to be a brown dwarf. Who knew? i say we come up with another classification for these planets... I don't know.... how about.... Onex's? We could start a cult! The cult of the Onex planets! We could recruit all the 2012ers.... Mel Gibson.... Lil' Waine.... the possibilities are endless!

Answer 4

it must exist before it can be characterized.

Answer 5

HAHAHAHAHA! There's no such thing as a Planet X!

Answer 6

Planet X is a invisible, massless ghost planet.

A brown dwarf or a red giant would be visible even many light years away.  

Answer 7

planet x is fictional.

though 2 new planets are recognized now in our solar system ceres and eres

they are both solid dwarfs

Answer 8

This stuff is all lies and fraud to get people buying faked up books, videos, watching nonsense shows on TV and directing traffic to fraudulent websites.

Planet X / black hole / brown dwarf / wandering planet is non-existent. It was predicted for 2003 by a loony woman who claimed telepathic contact with aliens.  No sign of it then and still no sign of it.  If this big nasty exists it must be quite close by now and visible with a fairly ordinary astronomical telescope.  Where is it?  The assumption that it can only be seen from the southern hemisphere and therefore astronomers don’t see it is nonsense, there are many large optical and some radio astronomical telescopes in Chile and Australia.

This is all fraud, superstition and abject delusion.  

Answer 9

If those you "hear' can't make up their minds what they're talking about,

why do you believe anything they say?