Is stoning for zina halal according to the four madhabs and al-Albani??

Question

Is stoning for zina halal according to the four madhabs and al-Albani??

Answer 1

absolutely NOT permissible,in fact this punishment is like inviting wrath of Allah Allmighty..Glorious Quran DOES NOT permit this punishment,be it married or un married,regardless of marital status.

those who believe in Rajam,automatically believes that Glorious Quran is not complete and its verses were eaten by goat

@ Meekal dont fall into satan's trap of this abrogation thing.

Answer 2

i don't think so

in Muslim this is sharya law

Answer 3

THERE IS NO STONING IN QURAN FOR PUNISHMENT

Answer 4

There is a couple of Ahadith in Sahih Bukhari in which 'Umar is reported to have talked about "the verse of the Rajam" which was revealed but was not to be written into the Qur'an.

I have, so far, heard two arguments regarding this issue. One of them suggests how these Ahadith are actually later fabrications of people who didn't want to loosen the penalty for adultery and so they had to agree with this opinion and thus it crept into Bukhari and later scholars came up with the idea of Mansukh Tilawa (abrogated by recitation) to state the the verse was meant to be abrogated by recitation but its ruling was to remain.

The other argument agrees that the verse was a part of the Qur'an and uses different other narrations to prove that it was abrogated by recitation but its ruling remained.

Moreover, it doesn't make sense why would the prophet (pbuh), 'Umar, or even the other companions know about the existence of such a verse and not write it down unless it was meant to be "abrogated verbally" or it was never a part of the Qur'an. I actually agree with the first argument which states that it was never a part of the Qur'an but I don't mind if the the second argument is the true one.

As a matter of fact, I think the stoning for adultery was originally found in the Torah, as mentioned in the Hadith, if I'm not wrong.

Anyways, the stoning that the so-called "Madhhabs" talk about is for married people who commit adultery not for people who are not married.

Allah knows best.

Answer 5

Well, no.

Can someone please give some verses to prove it is halal?

Answer 6

Yes, it is.

Answer 7

there is no such thing in islam. Stoning to death has no basis in Islam. The punishment for zina is clearly laid down in the Quran:

"The woman and the man guilty of illegal sexual intercourse, flog each of them with a hundred stripes"[24:2]

100 lashes for both male and female. Quran does not make distinction between married and unmarried adulterers; this stems from hadith.

Since the Quran should always be the highest authority and should always be above hadith if one contradicts the other, stoning to death has NO basis in Islam.