Is this a fair fantasy football trade????

Question

i am giving up steven jackson and aaron rodgers. i am getting peyton manning and willie parker.

Answer 1

It is a fair trade, but I am VERY  high on S.Jax this year so I probably would not do the trade.  On the flip side, Favre may end up staying and starting in GB.  Watch it closely.

Answer 2

do it peyton is a major upgrade pitts.always runs the ball

Answer 3

Take it, Manning is going to get you at least around 20 points a week and Jackson MAY get you 10-15 but might not. Watch the waiver wires and injury reports for good RB pick ups...remember, RB's like Grant weren't even drafted last year... Rodgers may not even start and if he did he may not be a great fantasy player either....at least he's not a known star like Manning. Personally, I think people are down on Parker because of the hype but really, the best back starts no matter what system you play in so I think giving up Jackson for Parker may end up being a wash.  

Answer 4

You're getting a great QB, but you're getting a major setback at RB. Parker is nowhere near what Jackson is and is also very injury prone. I'd say that you should do it, and just hope that Parker stays healthy.

Answer 5

Make the deal! Manning is always reliable for big numbers and Parker will continue to emerge. Stephen Jackson is a great player. However, there is no guarantee that Rodgers will be the Packers starting QB. Favre has returned to Packers training camp and its a good bet that Rodgers is going to get screwed.

Answer 6

Well more than likely aaron rodgers isnt even going to start now that Favre is back so I would do it just because your getting one of the best QB's in the league for someone whos not even going to play.

Answer 7

Good Deal.  Take is before it is gone!

Answer 8

NO its not fair to the other guy