Is this a fair trade offer for Brandon Webb?

Question

i'm thinking about offering a guy Chien Ming Wang, Jon Lester, and Chris Young (AZ OF) for Brandon Webb. do you think that's fair.

his OF are Victorino, Hinske, Matthews Jr., Schumaker, Francisco, and Gerut, so i thought he could use some OF help.

Answer 1

I'm not a big fan of 2 for 1 or 3 for 1 since it usually means I'd have to drop someone useful.  That guy's OF does look pathetic, but I'm not in love with Chris Young, his BA is too low, and Wang is in a terrible stretch and a terrible K guy in the first place, and Lester's still a bit of an unknown.  It might be fair, but if I had Webb I wouldn't take it, unless all three of those guys represent major upgrades over what he currently has at those spots

Answer 2

No, lester sucks, wang is fading, and young blows, and webb owns. Good Luck.

Answer 3

No way dude... Wang is a fantasy killer with his high whip and low K's, Lester's been alright but if you take away his no hitter he's mediocre and Chris Young kills Ks and avg (which isn't that bad).

Webb is a perennial top 5 pitcher in the ML, would you do the trade if you have Webb?

Answer 4

You need to offer better than that.

Answer 5

not a good enough offer, both pitchers you are offering are not that good, and CY is not enough for Webb. Move CY into your outfield and offer him a better outfielder.