Is this a good birthday idea? Please help me...?

Question

So my original idea for a birthday gift backfired - I got my fiance a really cool fire pit (he wanted badly), but now we are moving into a condo and can't have it. I haven't even gotten to give it to him yet, and am trying to sell it....grr...

Anyway, my other idea was this - he is a really big movie buff (is a videographer) and a huge fan of the movie Fight Club. He's joked several times in the past about wanting to have the robe that Tyler wears in that movie, and I found it on the internet.

Is this a dumb present, or cool? Men please answer (espeically male movie fans). http://www.bathrobeshoppe.com/coftalakabra.html

Thanks!

You really have to have seen and liked the movie to 'get' this... If you haven't seen it, you will DEFINITELY think this is stupid...

If not, please provide an alternate suggestion?

Answer 1

I think he would love it. When you get them something they have hinted at in the past it shows them you listen to them. Great work finding that perfect gift!

Answer 2

As a guy I can tell you.. we all have our favorite parts in movies.. If you get us memorabilia.. well thats just plain awesome.

Answer 3

If you can find out,which you have already done, and buy something he would like to have but ordinairly wouldn't buy for himself then it's a wins , wins situation.

Answer 4

Hey....you know what he likes right?

Nothing like getting him something you know he'll like. Stick with it. Its a good idea.

Answer 5

I've seen the movie.  It's an awesome idea.  

Answer 6

That is one of my ALL TIME FAVE movies.  I knew exactly what you were talking about before i even clicked on the link.  But thanks...I am going to order one for myself now.  :O)

I would definitely get him that.  It is a really funny and cute idea.  But maybe also just do something fun.  Take him out for even just a little celebration.  While the robe is an awesome idea, I would just maybe take him out for a couple of beers or do something out of the ordinary to make his day even more special and provide even more memories.

Good job on the gift!