Is this a good deck for yugioh?

Question

monster reborn x3

red eyes b chick

dragon capture jar

gravi crush dragon

kuriboh

legacy of yata garasu

de spell x3

polymerization

return zombie

swift gaia the fierce knight

silver fang

mammoth graveyard

change of heart x3

curse of dragon

winged dragon guardian of the fortress #1

summoned skull x2

feral imp

dark magician

chopman the desperate outlaw

ansatsu

fissure

giant soldier of stone

mystical elf

spellbinding circle

red eyes black metal dragon

red eyes b. dragon

metalmorph

time wizard

monster reincarnation

swords of revealing light

zombyra

twin headed behemoth

celtic guardian

Answer 1

Right, lets presume that you dont have that much money, and therefore the majority of your cards will be coming from starter decks...

First I relisted your cards to help organise the analysis.

Monsters------------------------(23)

red eyes b chick

gravi crush dragon

kuriboh

return zombie

swift gaia the fierce knight

silver fang

mammoth graveyard

curse of dragon

winged dragon guardian of the fortress #1

summoned skull x2

feral imp

dark magician

chopman the desperate outlaw

ansatsu

giant soldier of stone

mystical elf

red eyes black metal dragon

red eyes b. dragon

time wizard

zombyra

twin headed behemoth

celtic guardian

Spells---------------------------(13)

monster reborn x3

monster reincarnation

swords of revealing light

fissure

change of heart x3

de spell x3

polymerization

Traps------------------------------(4)

dragon capture jar

metalmorph

spellbinding circle

legacy of yata garasu

--------------------------------------...

Can I start by saying well done for sticking to the 40 card limit (which will unfortunatly be one of the kinder things said.) Many new players start with 50-60 cards from the get-go, and at least you have basic knowledge of the smaller the deck, the better the chances of getting the right cards. However...

The simple answer to your question is no, to be blunt. Even assuming the deck was in the Limited Format rather than Advanced, you still have 4 cards that you can't play - CoH and MR are restricted to one in limited format play. Also, you deck contains lots of Vanilla creatures (monsters without effects) and high level monsters which also share the same fate.  However, I cant give you much advice as I dont have a clue what cards you have, the only thing i will say is "REMOVE RED EYES BLACK METAL DRAGON" as that card is possibly the worst card in the game. The only way to summon him is to tribute a REbD with Metalmorph on him, and simple maths shows (REBD+MM= 2700ATK + 1/2 Enemy ATK) is better than (REBMD - 2800).

Simply put, buy some boosters, or get some tins (or even a new structure deck, the newest one holds a powerful dark monarch, and a bunch of legal, decent cards, at a reasonable price.) Or just buy 3 Machine Revolt decks and play gadget monsters :D.

Answer 2

i didnt read all of it but i kno u r only allowed to have 1 monster reborn in ur deck