Is this a good pre season fantasy football trade?

Question

Marvin Harrison and Kellen Winslow for Dwyane Bowe and Jeremy Shockey.

Answer 1

Seems like a pretty even trade...just depends on what you would rather have I guess.

BTW..check out my fantasy Q&A http://sites.google.com/site/fantasyfoot...

Answer 2

No, keep Kellen Winslow.

Answer 3

Depends on who's getting who.If you have Harrison and Winslow then its not a good move.If your Bowe and Shockey then yes it is.Winslow is good and has come on as of late while Harrison even thought at an old age hasnt lost in his production.Bowe is still young and will take some time to know whether he is a good player or not.Shockey coming off an injury needs to show what he's capable of doing in his new happy go offense.

Answer 4

why would you ever get rid of Harrison

Brodie Croyle is just too inexperienced to carry the load for kc

Answer 5

I would stick with Harrison and Winslow. Shockey might have a good year, but Winslow will finish in the top 3. Bowe is nice, but not spectacular so I would roll the dice and hope Harrison plays all year.