Question:

Is this a good top 5 award voting for MLB?

by  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

American League

MVP: 1. Josh Hamilton 2. Mark Texiera 3. Xavier Nady 4. Carl Crawford

5. Nick Markakis

Cy Young 1. Cliff Lee 2. Mike Mussina 3. John Lackey 4. Joe Saunders 5. Roy Halladay

Rookie 1. Evan Longoria 2. Justin Christian 3. Jed Lowrie 4. Chris Carter 5. Brandon Boggs

Gold Gloves

1B: Kevin Youkillis Redsox

C: Kevin Cash Redsox

2B: Alexi Ramirez Whitesox

3B: Eric Chavez Athletics

SS: Derek Jeter Yankees

LF: Carl Crawford Rays

CF: Curtis Granderson Tigers

RF: Bobby Abreu Yankees

P: Mike Mussina Yankees

National League

MVP: 1.Ryan Howard 2. Aramis Ramirez 3. Chipper Jones 4. Albert

Pujols 5. Manny Ramirez

Cy Young: 1. Brandon Webb 2. Tim Lincecum 3. Edinson Volquez

4. CC Sabathia 5. Ryan Dempster or Aaron Cook (your pick Cook or Dempster?)

Rookie: 1. Geovanny Soto 2. Jay Bruce 3. Edinson Volquez 4. Argenis Reyes 5. Daniel Murphy

Gold Glove

1B: Derrek Lee Cubs

C: Russell Martin Dodgers

2B: Brandon Phillips Reds

3B: David Wright Mets

SS: Jimmy Rollins or Hanley Ramirez (Who would you pick Rollins?)

LF: Josh Willingham or Carlos Lee (Who would you pick Lee?)

CF: Mike Cameron or Carlos Beltran (Who would you pick Carlos?)

RF: Hunter Pence

please respond for gold gloves as you respond back for the 1vs.1 gold glove fights vote and i will count the votes and release them

 Tags:

   Report
Answer The Question I've Same Question Too

12 ANSWERS

Sort By: Date  |  Rating

  1. No actually not that good. I have seen better.

    Craford? Nady? MVP?

    Mussina? Lackey? Saunders? All ahead of Halladay?

    I won't even get to gold gloves.


  2. I am actually suprised at the level of thought that must have been put into this it is a fairly accurate list in my opinion here are my $.02

    1. X nady has not done enough in the AL to merit even consideration for MVp

    2. As of todoy Brondon Webb is not the favorite to win the NL cy young most espn writers and myself agree that Lincecolm has all but locked it up

    3. For the gg questions on NL i would go with Rollins Lee and Cameron

    4. Manny is not even in consideration for NL MVP he has not been in the league long enough

    5. I noticed you had no pitcher for NL gg and i woul recomend Greg Maddux who has 11 in a row

  3. No! u r terrible

  4. hanley makes a lot of errors.

  5. Sorry but no.  Volquez is not a rookie,  Carlos Quentin is the front runner for AL MVP.  Alexi Ramirez should be considered for AL ROY. Carlos Lee is a horrible fielder,  Jeter is not a GG ss.  I could go on.

  6. Dang, I hardly agree with any of these, no offense.

    MVP for AL is almost certainly going to be Carlos Quentin or Josh Hamilton, probably Quentin because his team is contention.

    Cy Young, you're right on with both leagues in my opinion.

    Rookie AL: Evan Longoria, David Murphy, Alexei Ramirez are the top three picks to me.

    Rookie NL: Geo Soto for certain... Though Jay Bruce has been really good.

    For the Gold Gloves, I don't understand how people continue to say that Jeter is a Gold Glover!!! I think he's a great leader and I respect him and all that, but he is consistently in the bottom 5 in fielding percentage!  And Eric Chavez hasn't played enough to be considered.  All the people you named seem to be people with big names and flair, not consistent players with high fielding percentages.  



    For the NL Gold Gloves, I don't watch enough to make a fair assessment.

    So, there's my opinion.


  7. MVP AL: 1. Carlos Quentin 2. Hamilton no one else has a chance

            NL: 1. Pujols 2.Braun 3. Berkman

    CY YNG AL: Lee no one else has chance

                 NL: Webb, CC, Lincecum

    ROY AL: obviously longoria

            NL: soto then bruce

    who cares about gold gloves

  8. AL Cy Young. There is no way Halladay is 5th in the running. He has recieved 14 runs of support (IIRC) in his 9 losses and has great numbers accross the board. Lee no doubt should be #1 but Halladay should be at #2.

    Hamilton for MVP with Quentin a close second...

    Kevin Cash for a Gold Glove? Eric Chavez who has barely played this season for a Gold Glove?

    I dont think Nady and Manny will have enough at bats tro qualify for MVP in their new leagues.

    I would have Volquez above of Bruce in NL ROTY.

    Doesn't Jacoby Ellsbury qualify for AL ROTY. I would consider him 2nd behind Longoria.

    Rollins over Hanley because Hanley makes more errors. Lee over Willingham and Beltran over Cameron.

  9. Disagree w/ like all of this

  10. No.

    You made absolute BULLCRAP calls for MVP.  Teixiera?  Nady? Manny?  Not even in the top 25.

    Mussina isn't number #2 in Cy Young, K-Rod should be there.

    Your Gold Gloves suck too.  Cash?  No. Chavez?  He's hurt.  Jeter?  No.  Crawford? No.  Abreu?  DEFINITELY not.  Willingham?  lol, no.  Lee?  Injured.  (Braun wins it in left)

    I couldn't have made WORSE picks.

  11. technically Volquez isn't a rookie

    i'd go with Beltran over Cameron

  12. Uhh no.  Sorry.  I'm a huuuuuuuuge Phillies fan, but I really think Ryan Howard is overrated and has not shot at MVP.  Chase Utley should definately be on that list.  Come on, he's the best second baseman in the game.  (Is your favorite team an AL team??)  And Jimmy Rollins has been having a terrible year.  For the Mets, Wright's not doing so great either...he's just okay.
You're reading: Is this a good top 5 award voting for MLB?

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 12 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.
Register Now
Unanswered Questions