Is this a good trade for me? ?

Question

I give Marion Barber and Mark Clayton. I get Plaxico Burress and Thomas Jones.

Answer 1

Nah, unless you think Plaxico will do better than Barber this season...which I doubt.

Answer 2

Dont do it....you already have 3 excellent wr's so there is no need for another..

Answer 3

A healthy Burress this year means Pro Bowl if he doesnt' get hurt again (although he's got a lot of cometition at WR in NY).

Thomas Jones will get a lot of strain off his back with Favre flinging passes left and right and he'll probably share the load with Washington.

Tough call, but I like Jones.  He's a workhorse with great vision.

Answer 4

i wouldnt give up barber.

Answer 5

No, keep Barber.

Answer 6

No.

A top 10 running back is practically invaluable, and the return you'd get here does not match what Barber brings.

EDIT -

Without a doubt, no. Hold on to Barber, especially since you don't have a RB that could fully assume starting duties if Thomas Jones didn't pan out.