Is this trade offer fair?

Question

I lose:

Tony Romo

Santonio Holmes

I get:

David Garrard

Thomas Jones

I need a #2 RB badly as Matt Forte is currently my starter opposite Addai. I can afford to give up Holmes as I have Andre Johnson and Torry Holt.

Would you make that trade?

Answer 1

do not do it romo will make up for  your rb slacking. besides matt forte is a sleeper rookie this year. please,please keep what you have

Answer 2

I wouldn't do it !!

Answer 3

I would not make this trade. Even though David Garrard is a solid Quarterback, Romo produces much more. If you can afford to lose Santonio Holmes, thats fine, but you shouldn't lose Tony Romo while you're at it.

See if you can take both Quarterbacks out of the trade and just trade Santonio and some other average guy at a position he needs, and remind him that Thomas Jones only had 1 rushing touchdown last year.