Is waterproof mascara worse for your eyelashes than normal mascara?

Question

Is waterproof mascara worse for your eyelashes than normal mascara?

Answer 1

Yes because when you are washing it off you have to scrub harder to get it off and it tends to pull out some lashes! Hope i helped!

Answer 2

Well it can be harder to take off because you will have to rub your eyelashes a lot.  

Answer 3

No, its not worse for your eyelashes.  You just need to have an oil-based eye makeup remover to take it off.  It WILL NOT come off with soap & water.  I had some on 2 weeks ago & tried to just wash it off with my regular face wash & it wouldn't come off.  Finally I put some Vaseline on it to break it up & then washed my face... it worked, but I had to really rub my lashes with tissue.  Vaseline isn't the best either--its too thick.  The remover has to be oil based & it will come off easily.  I lost about 2 eyelashes using the Vaseline, it was just sticky & goopy & I had to rub too hard.  The oil based remover will not do that.