JB Fans + Haters.....?

Question

So there's been alot of talk about the Jonas Brothers being compared to the Beatles lately..and I hope alot of you will agree with me when I say that's bullshit.

Exhibit A:

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AnRx9IfH8JTzGRoTJc0u3N3ty6IX;_ylv=3?qid=20080820135344AAieZYk&show=7#profile-info-9ff1iQmmaa

I know one fan doesn't speak for everyone. I'm not about to judge anyone personally just based on their musical taste. I mean, I'm a performer and musician myself. I've seen the industry first hand, it's a cutthroat, ****** up place, but great that some people do actually make it and can live the lifestyle. I'm only fourteen, but I'm one of the very few who really hasn't caught onto the whole Jonas madness. To be quite honest, I haven't really gained much respect for them as artists yet. Everything down to the guitars is just a few repetitive power chords. Putting my own taste aside, that's just me looking at it technically from a musical point of view.

I know this isn't the first Jonas/Beatles question, and it certainly won't be the last. I'm not posting this question as FANS ONLY or any of that; that approach is pretty ridiculous. I've seen it countless times on here, and you really can't block out other people's opinions. That's just the way the world works.

All in all, my question, for fans and haters, would you SERIOUSLY compare the Jonas Brothers to the Beatles?

Answer 1

no i would not

im 14 too and i wasnt caught up in jonas madness either. luckily, my dad gave me some good CDs before it all happened. i was listenin to the dead and iron maiden while everyone else was listenin to JB...

Answer 2

Dollie, that question (Exhibit A) just shows that stupidity is infinite.

Answer 3

the jonas brothers being considered music is ridiculous on its own.

the only reason people would say that the jonas sisters are better then the Beatles would be that they have never heard real music in their life. The jonas sisters are for 10 year olds, and it should stay that way. It's ridiculous how many teens really need to grow up and open their mind to something a lot more real then the jonas posers.

Answer 4

Anyone who says c**p like that should be sat down, forced to take History Of Rock Roll, and Popular Music Appreciation classes. They have not a clue has anything of real musical worth.

Answer 5

The  only comparison I can see, are the crazed fans.

Musically there is NOTHING to compare. The Beatles were/are great musicians, they're legends what else can be said about them.

EDIT: Give the Jonas fans some time, they're young and they'll soon realize just what REAL music is. You've seemed to have figured it out at a young age, but for some it takes a little longer.

Answer 6

Hmmm

Well, the Beatles are WAY!!! better

But have you seen footage of them in concerts, getting off airplanes? MADNESS! Woman all around being swooned, some even fainting.

The Jonas Brothers? CRAPPY MUSIC!

But same situation as the Beatles, girls LOVE them.

But really, I don't see anything to love about them, the Jonas Brothers. They ugly muthafuckahs

Answer 7

dudette get a life plz....

Answer 8

The Beatles and the little Jonas boys shouldn't even be mentioned in the same sentence. The Beatles broke up 38 years ago and their music is still as alive as it was back then - the Jonas brothers will be lucky if they're still around in 38 months or weeks.

Answer 9

The beatles rocks the JoBros' sucks !!

Answer 10

The Jonas Brothers being compared to anyone outside of the new age disney channel is bull.

Answer 11

Listen dollie, first of all the jonas brothers are gr8 and second of all if you think the jonas brothers arent gr8 listen to ali lohan yeah theyre bettter than the beatles next to her!!! and the jonas brothers arent replacing the beatles theyy are just the hearththrobs band of this century popstars and rock bands change from time to time  you know