James Loney or Evan Longoria?

Question

My team is very well balanced, so I don't need one stat more than another. (also we use .OPS instead of batting average, but we also use Hits as a stat).

I currently have James Shields, and a manager will offer me either of the above players for him. I know, i know, Shields is solid, but look at his split stats... he's TERRIBLE in June and July.

Answer 1

Evan Longoria is an awesome 3rd baseman.  I would hold off though and keep James Shields.  He has grown up a little and will be a solid part of the Rays rotation.

Answer 2

For the idiot saying to Keep Loney, he doesn't have Loney.  He's getting offered Loney.

Definitely go with Longoria.

Answer 3

Keep Loney..

HA HA... yes, take advice from a guy with an ape head..brilliant.