James Toney v. Evander Holyfield at 190?

Question

James Toney v. Evander Holyfield at 190?

Answer 1

both in their prime,  wow what a great fight --  Toney by decision

Answer 2

holyfield would have hit harder at 190, so he wares down toney and wins a decision.

Answer 3

Personally, I think James Toney was at his best at supermiddle and light heavyweight. After seeing him against Jirov, who was the cruiserweight king at the time, I thought he was being outworked in the beginning and middle rounds. Even though fatigue effected Jirov greatly, I thought if it wasn't for the low-blow deduction and getting knocked down in the final round, then Toney would have lost a close decision or earned a draw at best.

I think Holyfield was one of the greatest, if not the greatest, to fight at cruiserweight. Holyfield at cruiserweight was much better than Jirov was at cruiserweight. I could see Holyfield getting an early lead and holding on to it down the stretch.