James Toney(1993)v Joe Calzaghe(2000),12 rounds,super middle?

Question

who would have won had these two met at the peak of their careers?

Answer 1

joe calzaghe wasnt at his peak when he was 2000, so obviously it would of been toney. but joe would kick his A55.

Answer 2

Toney would wipe him out.  Calzaghe needs a straigh ahead type of fighter to be successful; Toney is the ultimate slick counterpuncher, plus he hits about 10x harder, has a better chin, and handspeed.

Toney at his peak could beat just about anyone, and that easily includes Joe Calzaghe.

Answer 3

Toney

Answer 4

calzaghe