Jason Varitek or Dioner Navarro?

Question

Who would you rather have as catcher for the 2nd half of the season? I know Tek's been poor lately but surely he will improve?

My other catcher is Mr Victor Martinez currently on the DL.

thanks for your help

Answer 1

Navarro without any hesitation.

Answer 2

I think Varitek's days of an offensive producer are pretty much over. I find it hard to believe that he can be this bad... but at this point I have to believe he is one of those guys who are a much better baseball player in real life than in fantasy.

With Navarro you get someone who will at least bat for a decent average this year and will not hurt you as much as 'Tek will. The Rays are hot and scoring in bunches. This can only help Navarro's numbers.

Answer 3

navarro will be better choice,,i'm huge sox fan but tek's bat has been dwindling more and more every year

Answer 4

Dioner,  he is younger and with the better team right now I have to go with him.  He is also hitting well.  Varitek is in a slump right now.  If the Red Sox win more then him.  I know he has caught more perfect games than anyone but still, right now I have to go with Navarro.  Plus,  I used to be a Red Sox fan and now(because I went down to Florida and say a Rays game) I am a fan of the Rays more now.