Jirardi or torre?

Question

Who do you find to be more of a better influence to the roster?

Id say jirardi because he is very in tune with the players, does not seem to get mad, and embraces the fans, which I think is key ( i live in the bx.) Torre was cool, but jirardi brings a freshness to the team.

Answer 1

Last year, I wanted to keep Torre over Girardi.

This year, I'd rather keep Girardi than replace Torre.

Its not that one is better than the other- its that they are different and both good at their particular things.

I think Girardi as a manager is like having a student teach the class, because it wasn't that long ago he was on the roster with many of the same guys that are on the field now. Maybe, they listen to him more because of it... Because he's not uncool and old like the teacher?

Answer 2

They both have diff style of coaching, torre is mostly a players coach and lets the players just play. Girardi seems to trust the players a little more and that shows with the effectiveness of the bullpen. I would have to say Torre though he did win 4 championships. If Girardi wins a championship this year he will be a savior but Torre will always be my fave, and i hate the way he got treated after what he did for the yanks.

Answer 3

I will take Torre for now, when the New Yankee Coach wins a world series then he will be out of Torres Shadow in New York!

Answer 4

Girardi is doing okay, and he was a good catcher, so yeah, he does have a connection with the players, but Torre is just a great person, hes nice, but knows a lot about the game, and I respect him a lot for the things he achieved with the Yankees.  Steinbrenner just wanted it all, and got greedy, and basically fired him.  It wasn't good enough to get to the playoffs EVERY YEAR, and not win the world series, and now there is a good chance they wont even get there, which is sad, but serves him right.  So I choose Torre.

Answer 5

It is Giradi

Answer 6

Well Girardi has been here less than a Year and to me he has done okay , but  being that said to me he has to prove he can win BIG in New York and i mean Championships

and Torre he has a special place in my heart so, i choose Torre

Answer 7

Girardi is a Clubhouse cancer, there is a reason why the Ex-Cub is not the manager of the Cubs now.  Steinbrenner likes the big name and no substance, that is Giradi.  The Yankees are not winning because of him, but in spite of him.

Torre is a HOF manager, he has had an injury plagued team all year, and is still in contention.

MARK MY WORDS, you Yankees fans will be running Giradi out of town much sooner than Stieinbrenner ran Torre out of town.

Answer 8

girardi, he's newer and is now closer to the players.