Joba Chamberlin for Adrian Gonzales a good trade?

Question

Joba Chamberlin for Adrian Gonzales a good trade?

Answer 1

I'd like the Gonzales side of the deal much more.

Answer 2

if you need power hitting and homeruns its good because they usually take joba out right before he can get a win

Answer 3

Yes, Joba is overrated.

Answer 4

If the guy's willing to give away that much power, then yes. Chamberlain isn't that great as a starter and Gonzalez will help you a lot in hitting. He has more than enough power to help you overcome your loss of Chamberlain.

Answer 5

The Yankees have no pitching whatsoever. Why would they trade a YOUNG starting pitcher for a 1st basemen, when they already have one in Giambi? The Yanks need a pitcher if anything, not another 1st basemen.

Answer 6

Do it, Joba is not that great as a fantasy player and Gonzales is consistent. I have Adrian as my first baseman and he ranks as one of the top first basemen in the league.