Joe Saunders or Tim Hudson?

Question

Trading Uggla for a starting pitcher....I have been offered Saunders from one guy and Hudson from another. Which would you take and why, or neither? Seems like a coin flip to me......

Answer 1

Take Saunders.  He has a better team (easier to win b/c more runs for him).  He also has a pretty good ERA.  Hudson also seems to be less reliable.  When I had him on my team for a short while, he didn't have reliable starts.

BK

Answer 2

Saunders, he's WAY better than Hudson this yr.

Answer 3

i'd take saunders over hudson cuz he's on a better team and he's had better numbers except for strikeouts

but why are you trading uggla? who do you have at second to replace him?

Answer 4

You could get a better pitcher for Uggla, someone like a Lackey, I think