Josh Hamilton Trade- HUGE! help?

Question

my OF is fine- i have crawford , bruce , berkman-hes an OF too-so i really need pitching....should i accept this

i would give

Josh Hamilton-Brandon Webb-Miguel Tejada

I would receive

Roy Halladay

Carlos Zambrano

Jose Reyes

it seems fair to me

thanks - yes or no and why-giving 10 pts to best answer

Answer 1

depends who ur SS is, if u really need to upgrade that, then maybe. But if it was me, I wouldn't do it, Webb is doing good. and Hamilton and Tejada are also doing good. So if it was me i wouldnt do it.

Answer 2

Well to me i would take it if you want the pitching but if you didn't need it and stuff dont go threw with it to and plus if you did make the trade yuo would get more speed possible to for Jose Reyes.

Answer 3

The issue, as I see it, is whether you need an outfielder or the pitcher worse.  I think that you are over-rating Bruce.  You would get an improved shortstop and two excellent pitchers for one.  If you are comfortable with Bruce in your outfield, make the deal.

Answer 4

Just do Halladay and Reyes for Webb and Tejada.  You will be happy that you did that.  Hamilton has caught fire this year and Zambrano has slowed down and isn't the kind of threat he once was.  That is just my opinion, but that is what I would say.

Answer 5

Definitley a good trade, you would get good pitching skills and give up moderate players.

People want Josh Hamilton because of the Homerun Derby..

Even though it really doesnt show any skill because they are the easiest pitches to hit :P hope that helps

Answer 6

Yea i'd go for it.

Answer 7

Yes pull the trigger. You are getting the better of the deal by far, especially with a solid OF already in play.

Answer 8

I would say yes

Answer 9

If it seems fair to you then go for it, though you're giving up a lot with Hamilton, especially since Bruce isn't exactly on a hot streak over the last few weeks.  If pitching is your only weakness then go with Halladay and Zambrano.  They're two of the most consistent pitchers in the majors from year to year.

Answer 10

yeah it seems good but you should get rid of Bruce he was just good for a week now he sucks

Answer 11

No!  You have probably the best hitter and pitcher in baseball and you want to trade for a hometown hitter Matt Holladay?  Jose Reyes is not having his best season and Carlos Zambrano could tank at any second and his Cubs are falling.  Webb is a winner even when his team does poorly.   Don't you pull that trigger