Kate McCann, if she lied about this, then why should we believe anythinf else that comes out of her mouth

Question

I remember Kate McCann saying that she "knew" Madeleine had been abducted, because "Cuddle Cat" had been placed high up on a shelf, but in the photos of the children's bedroom, you can see that "Cuddle Cat" is in fact laying on Madeleines (very neat) bed. Why would Kate state such a thing? Its obviously a lie, and its not as if she could have mistaken it, either it was on the shelf or it wasn't? It does sound very strange?

Answer 1

Why don't you phone the authorities with this new piece of evidence?  It obviously hadn't occurred to them.

When was the photo taken, by the way??

Answer 2

You are a rocket scientist!! Well for one, hun, things were moved around and lived in between the time they released the photo which was bnot the photos of the crime scene, they were after the fact, and for all you know may not have even been the same exact room. Your observation of the cat reveals nothing, other then you are playing judge and jury. If you are so interested, why not be productive and help with missing and exploited children vs. wasting time ridiculing people that you can only speculate about the truth or lies.

Answer 3

They have lied from the beginning but in their arrogance think it unthinkable that anyone should dare suggest such a thing! I would never believe a word that comes from them or their accomplice’s mouths they are utterly contemptible to say the least. They stink of guilt and make my skin crawl.

Answer 4

OK- this may sound horrible but I think Maddie is dead and their obviously not going to find her. Why are the McCaans getting more media attention than other missing children's families?

Yes I can sympathize with them and they shouldn't give up on her but why are they getting more media attention???

Answer 5

More McLies from the mouth of Kate.

||edit|| Doh f***y!! The picture clearly show Cuddle Cat ON THE PILLOW. It even says as much in the caption.

Go on have another look. Let's not have your sight blinded by the shining Godliness of Kate and Gerry. http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/new...

Answer 6

Perhaps someone moved "Cuddle Cat" before the photo was taken?  If a parent comes back to find a missing child and their favourite toy is still there, perhaps their first instinct is to pick up the toy which is a link to the child?

edit* It isn't "obviously" a lie, because the report even states that the photo was taken a couple of hours after she went missing.  The placing of a toy doesn't make them not guilty but it doesn't make them guilty either.  This is a pretty ridiculous point.

Answer 7

You should really approach the authorities with this. They are surrounded by too many guards for you to make a citizen's arrest ;)

Answer 8

She would've gotten away with it too if it hadn't been for that meddling cat!

Answer 9

Looks like you have better investigative skills than the Portuguese Police  force (not hard I suppose), why don't you drop them a line Sherlock?

Answer 10

The Sun as your source??? Case solved.

Answer 11

Placed out of reach were the words used. And the cuddle cat was placed on the dresser. OUT of reach of a small kid. That is a pink item of clothing on the bed. The cat is on the dresser.

Your edit to chris. Deduce is the correct word. I would like to remind you that the McCanns were desperate to get these files released so that they can FIND their daughter.  Have you seen the photofits that the PJs wouldn't show the world? Disgusting shameless Police Force.

Who says she is lying? You? Ah well then.

NEXT!

EDIT.... Find us a link to where either of Madeleines parents have said the Cuddle Cat was HIGH up on a shelf. They didn't , they said "it was out of reach"

Answer 12

The fact that she is a liar is common knowledge that is why she doesn't like questions.

But she will get what's coming to her; the arrogant, lying *****.

I wonder why she turned the cleaning lady away on the day, yet when the police got there the place was spotless as if no-one was living there.

What woman with three toddlers on holiday says NO to help with the cleaning?

Maybe she didn't want anyone in the room until the evidence was cleaned up and out of the way.

Answer 13

Obviously.Pfft!

She comes in the room sees her daughter missing.Spots the toy on the shelf and picks it up thinking 'that's odd,how did it get there?'Puts it down and runs out to get help.

Next?

You so want her to be guilty you're letting hatred cloud your common sense.

Missesse:Sarcasm does not change the fact that this could well have happened.One toy does not make a collection by the way.So you still haven't proved the obviousness of anything.

Answer 14

The whole affair is riddled with inconsistencies and ambiguities, unless the matter is re investigated right from the start and all of those involved subjected to rigorous interrogation then the matter will remain closed.

Answer 15

god why were you not on this case? you clearly have fantastic detective skills

edit: your source is 'the sun' ... haha brilliant.