Keeper League Question, who to keep?

Question

I play in a league that counts all yardage, including return yards.

I can keep 2 players. And I have Tom Brady, so that's a given.

I'm trying to decide between: Joseph Addai and Maurice Jones-Drew.

The Colts have Dominic Rhoades back so they could share carries again. MJD always splits carries, but he catches a lot of passes (which we get points for) and he returns kicks and punts (which we get points for also).

I need some insight and opinions. All serious feedback appreciated!

Answer 1

Rhodes isnt going to take many carries away from Addia. Rhodes will probably only get the ball on 3rd and short. MJD is going to get the ball in the goal line, Fred Taylor will be getting all the yards. MJD will get those return yards and receptions yards like you said but I dont think it will equal out to what Addia will give you. Plus Addia gets drafted around pick 5. and MJD gets drafted around pick 17. I  say Addai, no question. Good luck.

Answer 2

Jones-Drew will most likey have more AP yards because he returns more kicks and punts!

Answer 3

addai, no questions. I know addai has rhodes but MJD has Fred Taylor.