Keeper Trade Help?

Question

Do I win this trade in a keeper league where we keep 15?

I send King Felix, James Shields

I receive Joba, Jake Peavy

Thoughts?

Answer 1

Yes because you get 2 good keepers while you send 1 good keeper and a average pitcher.

Answer 2

I'd pull the trigger on that one for sure.  Felix is overrated at this point and Sheilds is pretty good...but Joba has been getting steadily better in the starting role and Peavy is already GREAT...so why not?  Peavy is still fairly young and Joba is obviously young, nothing too lose for this one.

Answer 3

Fo sho, joba will own and peavy does. Good Luck.

Answer 4

This is a hard one, but I say yes. King Felix is really young, and one of the best pitchers, but James Shields can be a little shaky. Joba is very young, and will develop very quickly and Peavy, well, he is in the top 5 in starting pitchers. You and the person you're trading to get good young pitchers. So I don't know who gets the better end, but I think you get the slightly better side.

Answer 5

i think that joba will be better in the long run than king felix

and peavy is and will be better than james shields

good trade