Keeper league draft tonight!?

Question

We each get 6 keepers and I have the first pick. Here are my choices:

Willis McGahee

Darren McFadden

Jamal Lewis

Michael Turner

Roddy White

Dwayne Bowe

Jonathan Stewart

I can't decide between McFadden and McGahee. I really don't like either of them but no one else is worth the first pick. I had a trade going that got me extra picks and I move down to the 5th spot but the guy backed out. Now I'm screwed.

Answer 1

no doubt in my mind... i'd snag McFadden for a keeper. if you keep 6, that's McFadden in the 7th round. McGahee may not even be the starter of his real team in a week or 2 w/ Rice on the team.

Answer 2

People are keeping 6 players each and McGahee and Lewis and Turner are out there?

But you should take McFadden in a keeper league.  He's got the best shot of being worth a keeper next year, and if you've already kept 6 players, then you probably have your starting RB's already.