Kidd or nash?

Question

Kidd or nash?

Answer 1

Jkidd couldn't hit the side of a house with a hose.   Nash has a good shot.   He drills all the midrange jumpers and can hit a three.

Nash is also an infinitely better playmaker than Kidd.

The only thing Kidd has on Nash is size and defense.

Answer 2

well..both r realy good but i gotta go with nash...

Answer 3

Nash all the way. kid is a little duoche bag

Answer 4

NASH no doubt about it

Answer 5

Nash but he cant shoot 3s

Answer 6

Stevy will be next J Kidd

Answer 7

Nash.

People say Nash has no D. But you have to look at his coaches - Don Nelson and Mike D'Antoni. Either one of them ask Nash to play defense. D'Antoni eve go as far as having Nash guard the worst offensive player on the other team even with size disadvantage (yeah, Kwame Brown, Bruce Bowen) to conserve energy for offense,

He's finally gotten a defensive minded coach in Terry Porter. That will make Nash a much better defensive player.

Answer 8

i hate Nash he is sorry on defense he doesn't attack the basket he just shoots 3 and misses half the time, so to me Kidd is better!!!!!who care about his MVP that he didn't deserve!!!!

Answer 9

Kidd no question he is better defensively while Nash is a better shooter for the guy that picked Nash because of his 2 Mvp's well Kidd had a MVP and 2 NBA finals apparances

Answer 10

yes, nash does miss his threes half the time, like you said. but, if you think for half a second, that means he makes the other half. shooting over fifty percent is pretty good (especially for a point guard), and almost 50% on threes is amazing.

now, if we look at jason kidd, what's his career shooting average? somewhere in the low forties? i'm not ripping kidd, he's a great player, but he's nowhere near the scorer--and recently, the distributor--that nash can be.

so i'm definitely going to go with nash.

Answer 11

I like Kidd better.

He is a triple-double machine unlike Nash

Answer 12

Steve Nash is a better shooter and all around player, but J Kidd is more experienced. However he can't shoot as consistently as Steve can. They can both pass just as good...I'd go with Steve.

Answer 13

kidd makes better decisions and has alot of triple doubles, while nash just fires 3 pointers all day.

kidd actually has defence also unlike nash and his suns.

kidd also passes the ball better.

now were talking point guards, right?

Answer 14

Kidd, he plays defense and is a better passer. The only thing Nash has on Kidd is the shooting, but defense is more important for a PG.

Answer 15

nash 2 mvp

Answer 16

NASH

Answer 17

Nash. Kidd slow now with no J. never had one. Nash still up in down the floor in a heartbeat with a J. just no D tho. in his prime i would pick Kidd over Nash tho. Nash was never a triple double waiting to happen plus a good defender like Kidd was in his prime.