Kobe or magic whos better

Question

better assists

better shot

better defence

better offence

better anything

Answer 1

Over All Magic (I Doubt Kobe Could Beat Aids)

Answer 2

kobes over rated

like lebron shaq chris paul tony parker

your should be asking magic or jordan  

Answer 3

Magic Johnson is the (much) better player than Kobe Bryant. Three times Magic won the MVP award (Bryant won once, so far). Five times Magic was an NBA champion, and was the main reason the Lakers won in the first place (Bryant is a three-time NBA champion, but Shaquille O'Neal was the reason why Kobe sports chamionship rings). Passing, clutch shooting, charisma, leadership, Magic Johnson blows Bryant out of the water. Could Bryant have played center during a pivotal NBA Finals game? Doubt it, but Magic did, and his versatility helped lead the Lakers to the 1980 championship...in his rookie year!

Answer 4

assists - magic

shot - kobe

defense - magic

offense - magic created more offense and kobe is the one doing the offense so it depends.

magic is the better all around player

Answer 5

they played in two different era's

kobe may be a great player now, but factor in all the rule changes that have happened in the time that magic played ball... you can now travel with the ball and the 3 point line is further away

guys like jordan, bird and magic were putting up unreal numbers in comparison to the players who play the ball today, but because of the rules people don;t notice that

in terms of assists magic is obviously better since he is second all time and retired very young due to his HIV when he could of been playing several more years and magic was just a better team player one of the greatest team players to ever play the game

in terms of shooting i would say kobe is a better shooter, but that is not to say that magic could not shoot... kobe just put up better numbers even if the rules favor him more then they did magic back in the day

magic was always on the top defensive players lists every year and kobe was never the lvl that magic was for this category

in terms of offense it's a toss up you have a guy like kobe who can single handedly win games on his own, as where a guy like magic was just a way better team player then kobe... magic could score 25 points per game and and up having 12 to 15 assists in a game... kobe can score 30+, but only distribute about 5 or 6 assists...

my vote is for magic

Answer 6

Kobe Bryant VS Magic Johnson

Analysis:

Assists - Magic Johnson is more of a team player guy. I agree, Kobe is better on his own. He can create opportunities by himself effortlessly.

EDGE : Magic is a better passer than Kobe.

Shot - I love how Magic shoot Jabbar's sky hook, but, that's it. Kobe's shot is arguably one of the most beautiful in the NBA.

EDGE : Kobe Bryant can shoot it lights out. I just don't know about Magic.

Defense - The best SG guard who can lock his defender one on one. A guy who loves challenges. The best player in the NBA.

EDGE : Kobe

Offense - As I've said, he creates opportunities for himself effortlessly. He is the guy you want the ball in his hands when time is running out to save or win your team.

EDGE : Kobe

Anything - Overall, Kobe Bryant looks better 2x than Magic. 81pts. X-factor.

As much as I like Magic, Kobe is a better player than him..

Answer 7

magic was more of a team player , kobe is better on his own

Answer 8

kobe is a great player now magic does what steve nash does now with a little more but they had never seen what magic did back then kobe would not be kobe with all the greats magic played with and agingst but magic could be a better steve nash right now but that is wat i think

Answer 9

John Stockton was the assists king. Kobe is total offence king.  Jordan was all around great.  Larry Bird was post shot king.  Karreem Abdul Jabbar was hook shot King.  Thats about all i have

Answer 10

Kobe is better

Answer 11

better assists

kobe

better shot

kobe

better defence

kobe

better offence

kobe

better anything kobe          kobe is like the perfect player  magic was good but not as good as kobe  

Answer 12

magic was one of jordans and birds rivals so magic had harder compition but kobe has to go up against lebron cris paul nask kevin garnet iverson

magic had to go up against michael jordan charles barkley kareem abdul larry bird dominique wilkins oscar robertson david robinson

john stockmon alonzo mourning

Answer 13

magic was good in his time and kobe is good right now so who cares

Answer 14

Magic is best at basketball

Kobe is best at rape and lying about it

Answer 15

81 pts doesnt make him better than Magic.

Magic could do it if he gets the ball every procession . and hog the ball everytime   or shoot everytime he gets the ball