Lendale white or Rashard mendenhall?

Question

Which one would you rather have in fantasy football for 2008

Answer 1

lendale. pitt's rb situation is always cloudy, since their style nearly guarantees injuries. on top of this, rashard might not even be the #2 rb. mewelde moore is on the team too.

Answer 2

watch out for lendale.......ill probbably kick myself ..but lendale will have a break out year

Answer 3

i dont think lendale will do great this year.  probably not a bad pick for a 3rd string rb in ur fantnasy team. mednenhall probably ur best bet. he only has parker to fight for over carries and u have to look at the teams steelers are a run oriented team. they run first pass after like the denver were for years. dont get me wrong steelers throw but they are a ground and pound running back team. titans i dont see them doing that good this year or lendale having a break out year

Answer 4

This would have been a more interesting question last year when White hadn't done anything and Tennessee looked like a team on the way down. I'd take White as a starter with a track record over a rookie. I like Mendenhall, but not as the choice in an either/or situation here.

Answer 5

lendale white is strong and will be faster than he was and no longer will compete with chris brown and hopefully will have a stronger line one less option to run means more yards for lendale! YAY LENDALE!

Answer 6

I would definitely go with White for this year.  I would rather have someone competing with a bunch of rookies than someone competing with Willie Parker.  Even if Mendenhall gets 3/4 of the rushing TDs in Pittsburgh, and that's best-case scenario, that won't be enough without the yards.  Parker is the RB you want in Pittsburgh.  Between Mendenhall and White I would definitely say White.

Answer 7

We need a crystal ball.

This is a question we can't yet answer.  Willie Parker is expected back healthy, but clearly the future is Mendenhall.

Lendale White has had a few moments, but largely has been disappointing, so much so that the Titans keep drafting guys to either motivate or replace him.

If it's a dynasty or keeper league, give me Mendenhall.

Standard leagues, given me White, and pray that Ernest Byner can talk some sense into him and keep him away from the buffet table.  He did have 1,100 yards last year...