Lengthening or volumizing mascara: which do you choose?

Question

i usually go for the thickness/volume factor. if it'll give me BOTH, then that's fine too.

Answer 1

i want volume

Answer 2

use the 2 step, first the white, than the black, i think it's cover girl, than go over it with something lighter.  

Answer 3

I def go for volume.

Answer 4

I dont have the longest eyelashes ever, but when i saw the MAC Plush lash mascara brush .. i thought it was cool so id try it, IT WAS AMAZING! And it was only 14 bucks! The first day i wore it I got compliments from girls I didnt know. And even my stuck up best friend asked me what i used.

Answer 5

volume, for sure :) i have fairly long lashes already,

so having both is definitely a plus. i use maybelline

volume express turbo boost waterproof in very black.

it adds a good bit of length in addition to great volume.

it seems to be the best and cheapest that i've found.