Question:

Lets Play <span title="Overrated/Underrated/Prooven?">Overrated/Underrated/Proo...</span>

by Guest58761 | earlier

Example: Aaron Rownand: Underrated

Example: Chase Utley: Prooven

Example: Manny RameriezL Overrated (I will get alot of c**p for that)

ok, here we go

Alex Rodriguez

Francisco Rodriquez (AKA K-Rod)

Matt Cain

Joba Cahmberlin

David Ortiz

Ryan Howard

Albert Pujouls

Jorge Posada

Jim Edmonds

Evan Longoria

Teams

Mets

Phillies

Rays

Yankees

Red Sox

Tigers

Twins

Angels

Thanks!

Stars Make Better Answers

Tags:

Report

Answer The Question I've Same Question Too

Follow Question

17 ANSWERS

Sort By: Date | Rating

1. Overrated

2. Prooven

3. Underrated

4. Overrated

5. Overrated

6.Prooven

7. Overrated

8.Overrated

9. Overrated

10. Prooven

Teams....

1. Prooven

2. Overrated

3. Prooven

4.Overrated

5. Prooven

6. Overrated

7. Underrated

8. Prooven
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Alex Rodriguez- Proven

Francisco Rodriquez (AKA K-Rod)- Underrated

Matt Cain- Underrated

Joba Cahmberlin- Underrated

David Ortiz- Proven

Ryan Howard- Proven

Albert Pujouls- Proven

Jorge Posada- Overrated

Jim Edmonds- Proven

Evan Longoria- Underrated

Teams

Mets- Overrated

Phillies- Underrated

Rays- Underrated

Yankees- Overrated

Red Sox- Overrated

Tigers- Overrated

Twins- Underrated

Angels- Underrated
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Alex Rodriguez - proven

Francisco Rodriquez (AKA K-Rod) - proven

Matt Cain - proven

Joba Cahmberlin - overrated

David Ortiz - proven

Ryan Howard - proven

Albert Pujouls - proven

Jorge Posada - overrated

Jim Edmonds - proven

Evan Longoria - proven

Teams

Mets - overrated

Phillies - proven

Rays - proven

Yankees - overrated

Red Sox - overrated

Tigers - overrated

Twins - underrated

Angels - proven
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Arod-proven

Krod-overrated

cain-maybe mildly overrated in some circles

joba-proven

ortiz-proven, but maybe a tad overrated

howard-proven, still a bit overrated

pujols-proven

posada-proven but old

edmonds-over the hill

longoria-excellent, proven
Report (0) (0) | earlier
a rod proven, no one is better than this guy

k rod proven, lights out

cain over rated

chamberlain prooven reliever over rated starter

ortiz proven, the guy is clutch how do you prove anymore than that

howard overrated, 150+ k's come on now

Pujouls proven

posada over rated

edmonds proven

longoria under rated

mets over

phillies over

rays under

yanks over for the last 8 years

red sox proven in the last 4 years

tigers wanabe yankees so overrated

twins under rated, good young pitching

angles under rated no one is talking about the best team in mlb
Report (0) (0) | earlier
PLAYERS:

overrated: jorge posada

proven: alex rodriguez, francisco rodriguez, david ortiz, ryan howard, jim edmonds

underrated: matt cain, albert pujols, evan longoria, joba chamberlain

TEAMS:

overrated: yankees, tigers, phillies

proven: red sox, angels

underrated: mets, rays, twins
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Alex Rodriguez-proven

Francisco Rodriquez (AKA K-Rod)-proven

Matt Cain-underrated

Joba Cahmberlin-overrated

David Ortiz-overrated

Ryan Howard-overrated

Albert Pujouls-proven

Jorge Posada-proven

Jim Edmonds-proven

Evan Longoria-underrated

Teams

Mets-overrated

Phillies-overrated

Rays-overrated

Yankees-proven

Red Sox-proven

Tigers-overrated

Twins-underrated

Angels-proven
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Alex Rodriguez- Proven, overrated at times

Francisco Rodriquez (AKA K-Rod)-proven

Matt Cain- i don't know

Joba Cahmberlin-proven, overrated at times

David Ortiz- proven

Ryan Howard- proven

Albert Pujouls- underrated

Jorge Posada-overrated

Jim Edmonds- i don't know

Evan Longoria- proven

Teams

Mets- overrated

Phillies- proven

Rays- proven

Yankees- proven at times, overrated at times

Red Sox- overrated

Tigers- overrated

Twins- underrated

Angels-proven
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Alex Rodriguez-proven

Francisco Rodriquez (AKA K-Rod)-proven

Matt Cain-under rated

Joba Cahmberlin-eh ill say proven

David Ortiz-right now over rated due to his play time and his bad play before the injury

Ryan Howard-proven

Albert Pujouls-proven

Jorge Posada-over rated due to injury

Jim Edmonds-under rated

Evan Longoria-proven

Teams

Mets-under rated

Phillies-over rated

Rays-proven

Yankees-over rated although they are playing d**n good right now

Red Sox-proven

Tigers-over rated

Twins-under rated

Angels-proven
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Alex Rodriguez (Prooven)

Francisco Rodriquez (AKA K-Rod) (Prooven)

Matt Cain (Underrated)

Joba Cahmberlin (Overrated)

David Ortiz (Prooven)

Ryan Howard (Prooven)

Albert Pujouls (Prooven)

Jorge Posada (Prooven)

Jim Edmonds (Overrated)

Evan Longoria (Underrated)

Teams

Mets (Prooven)

Phillies (Prooven)

Rays (Underrated)

Yankees (Prooven)

Red Sox (Prooven)

Tigers (Overrated)

Twins (Underrated)

Angels (Prooven)

Thanks that was Fun!
Report (0) (0) | earlier
A-Rod- Proven

K-Rod- Proven

Cain- Proven

Joba- Neither proven or overrated or underrated (needs time to be proven)

Ortiz- Proven

Howard- Proven

Pujols- Proven

Posada- underrated

Edmonds- Proven

Longoria- overrated

Teams:

Mets- underrated (at least for this year)

Phillies- overrated

Rays- overrated

Yankees- underrated (for this year)

Red Sox- Proven

Tigers- overrated

Twins- underrated

Angels- underrated
Report (0) (0) | earlier
A-Rod:Proven

K-Rod:Proven

Cain: Underated

Joba: Overated(should have kept him in bullpen til next year)

Ortiz: Proven

Howard: Overated

Pujols: Proven

Posada: Overated

Edmonds: Overated

Longoria: Overated

Mets: Overated

Phillies: Underated

Rays: Overated

Yankees: Proven(ouch that hurts)

Red Sox: Proven

Tigers: Overated

Twins: Underated

Angels: Overated(they seem to find a way to choke come playoff time)
Report (0) (0) | earlier
a-rod=proven

k-rod=proven

matt cain=?

joba chamberlain=overrated

david ortiz=overrated

ryan howard=overrated

albert pujols=proven

jorge posada=overrated

jim edmonds=overrated

evan longoria=underrated

mets=underrated

phills=overrated

rays=overrated

yankees=overrated

red sox=overated

tigers=underrated

twins=underrated

angels=underrated (by means of espn)
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Alex Rodriguez- Proven

Francisco Rodriquez (AKA K-Rod)- Proven

Matt Cain- Underrated

Joba Cahmberlin- overrated

David Ortiz- Proven

Ryan Howard-Proven

Albert Pujouls- Proven

Jorge Posada- Proven

Jim Edmonds- Overrated

Evan Longoria- Underrated

Teams

Mets- Underrated

Phillies- Overrated

Rays- Underrated

Yankees- Overrated

Red Sox- Proven

Tigers- Overrated

Twins- Underrated

Angels- Underrated
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Alex Rodriguez:

-proven. i hate him, but he's proven himself.

Francisco Rodriquez (AKA K-Rod):

-proven now. maybe not before this season, but certainly now.

Matt Cain

-very under rated.

Joba Cahmberlin

-over rated as a starter. proven as a reliever

David Ortiz

-proven. not because of his raw stats, but because of his performance in the clutch.

Ryan Howard

-proven, as a home run hitting monster that will continue to break his own strike out record.

Albert Pujols

-the most proven hitter in the game with A-Rod

Jorge Posada

-over rated. the new york media has put him out there as spectacular. i'd put him as an above average catcher. not top 5, or even top 10.

Jim Edmonds

-proven... to be a great defensive centerfielder with an above average bat that's well into the twilight of his career. meaning he now has an average bat at best, and above average defense on his good days, not every day.

Evan Longoria

-proven, as the rookie of the year favorite

Teams

Mets

-under rated, they have gotten a lot of negative press because of their slumps. they've gotten themselves the NL East lead now. and they've done it the hard way. taking 5 of the last 7 from the phillies.

Phillies

-over rated offense, it's streaky, very streaky.

-under rated pitching, cole hamels is the most under rated quality ace in baseball, and jamie moyers quite under rated as well

Rays

-proven, as a contender for the AL East. not a favorite, or a lock. but a contender to the end.

Yankees

-over rated. they are expected to be there because of their history and their team just isn't as good as the competition.

Red Sox

-proven as the defending WS champs.

Tigers

-proven as what everyone expected them to be at the beginning of the season. they might have dug themselves too big of a hole though.

Twins

-very under rated.

Angels

-proven as the best team in baseball
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Alex Rodriguez - Proven but not in playoffs

Francisco Rodriquez (AKA K-Rod) - proven saves record

Matt Cain - underrated enough said

Joba Cahmberlin - proven for his age look at the ERA

David Ortiz - underrated playoffs

Ryan Howard - overrated stikes out more than anyone

Albert Pujouls - underrated how many possitions can he play

Jorge Posada - proven he is injured but look at playoffs

Jim Edmonds - overrated just to old now

Evan Longoria - proven to young to tell

Teams

Mets - overrated watch them blow it

Phillies - overrated cant keep the mets back

Rays - overated watch them blow it

Yankees - underrated who picked them at the all star break

Red Sox - overrated Can hold back Rays and Yanks

Tigers - overrated enough said

Twins - underrated Wait till Liriano comes up from AAA

Angels - Overrated good pitching but cant beat yanks and soxs

Oh you forgot Jeter on you list underrated Mr. November
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Alex Rodriguez- proven

Francisco Rodriguez- proven

Matt Cain- underrated

Joba Chamberlain- proven

David Oritz- overrated

Ryan Howard- overrated

Albert Pujols- Proven

Jorge Posada- proven

Jim Edmonds- overrated

Evan Longoria- underrated

Mets- proven

Phillies- overrated

Rays- underrated

Yankees- proven

Red Sox- overrated

Tigers- overrated

Twins- proved

Angels-proven
Report (0) (0) | earlier