Liquid or Pencil Eyeliner?

Question

i am going to try out liquid tomorrow.

which do you guys like the best?

[liquid or pencil eyeliner.]

Answer 1

Pencil.  Liquid is harder to do, and can look harsh.  Pencil can be smudged to a softer look.

Answer 2

pencil you have to have a really steady hand to do liquid

mine?

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;...

Answer 3

Pencil!!

Can't maneuver liquid very well...

Answer 4

use liquid on top with a lil swoop

and pencil on bottom keep it light

and your good yo!!

Answer 5

I prefer liquid by far. It's harder to apply but has drastically better results. I think that the pencil goes on uneven and too thick compared to the liquid. I still keep pencil on hand and use it once in a while if I'm in a hurry but if I can, I'll always use liquid. It also stays on a lot longer I've been wearing it for over 24 hours now and it hasn't even smudged.  

Answer 6

pencil because it looks okay even if you're not using tons of makeup.

liquid is so bold that you have to have everything else on... foundation lipstick etc.  

Answer 7

liquid.

it gets really thick so rub it a little on some tissue paper and then put it on. dont worry about messing up because you can always touch it up with a q-tip. and it lasts much much longer and dosnt smudge. it stays perfect the entire day

Answer 8

Almay No Smudge Pencil, its the best out there!

Answer 9

i like both.

Liquid for the top

Pencil for the bottom

:D

yay!