MAC fluidliner vs. HIP cream liner

Question

which one is better?

Answer 1

MAC fluid liner sucks. I recently bought it thinking that it was going to be amazing, well it isn't. It cracks, and peels it doesn't stay on very long and if you have sensitive eyes definetely don't get it, it burns. It burns normal skin on your eyes too. HIP cream liner is amazing, it stays on all day, doesn't move, doesn't run, doesn't burn my eyes, I like the way it feels too. Hope this helps, sweetie!  (=

Answer 2

HIP cream liner is a less expensive product, stays on for a long time and gives an amazing colour.

However, MAC fluidline stays on for longer when used correctly, and when it is taken off you must use an oil-based make-up remover otherwise you will be there for ages!

Personally, I prefer MAC fluidline.  

Answer 3

I have the loreal HiP liner in black and I love it, it really easy to work with and stays on for a long time and is much cheaper!  

Answer 4

MAC fluid liner sucks. I recently bought it thinking that it was going to be amazing, well it isn't. It cracks, and peels it doesn't stay on very long and if you have sensitive eyes definetely don't get it, it burns. It burns normal skin on your eyes too. HIP cream liner is amazing, it stays on all day, doesn't move, doesn't run, doesn't burn my eyes, I like the way it feels too. Hope this helps, sweetie! (=

----

this is true... fluid line is just ok for what your paying for..

GET H.I.P. cleam liner it's pretty good but the color intensity isnt as good. and bobbi browns gel liner is good.

Answer 5

DEFINATELY HIGH INTENSITY PIGMENTS

NO DOUBT!!

i love it even though it can be a little hard to get off

but it never fails me

especially since the color stays on and doesnt fade

i l♥v it