MLB Power Pros 2008 vs Mario Sluggers?

Question

Which game should i get??

MLB pro 2008 around $40

Mario slugger around $50

and in mlb pro, for the success mode, can u play as the player in the league? or u have to create one

Answer 1

If you like Mario stuff get Mario Slugger.

IF u like more realistic rules get MLV Pro 2008 (this is still cartoonish).

But ill rather get Mario Slugger.

Answer 2

in depth baseball:power pros.  arcade baseball:mario sluggers.   I have both.