Madden 08 or NCAA 08?

Question

This is for Xbox 360.

Don't mention madden 09 and ncaa 09, because my parents won't let me have either of those.

And please dont mention other games that are not football related.

Answer 1

they both look good but go with mx vs atv untamed that is the best game  

Answer 2

NCAA, hands down.  Better graphics: the player's hands aren't stiff-looking, More options: you can save screenshots to show off that 98 yard kickoff return touchdown, the trophy case : nuff said, you can actually see the plays on the screen,  and best thing of all:

YOU DON'T HAVE TO HEAR MADDEN'S SUPER ANNOYING VOICE!!!

Good luck!!

Answer 3

madden 09 atw!!!!!!!

Answer 4

depends on what you like better, pro or college.

ncaa is a very simple game, none of that "star player" bs, just football.  

Answer 5

madden 08. it has some better features and if u have xbox live it has a bunch of streaming stuff from the internet. Plus i like NFL better than colleage. Plus NCAA doesn't use player names, just their numbers, really annoying!